Your December donations deserve more than a receipt and a hopeful glance at next year’s budget! Year-end donor retention strategies can turn the end-of-year generosity into a stronger fundraising pipeline for you next year.
Bloomerang’s Steve Isom shares how personal follow-up, second-gift planning, and better board reporting help nonprofits keep the momentum and the relationships going.
Steve, Bloomerang’s COO and CFO, shares how to connect donor stewardship with revenue planning. His starting point: think about every year-end gift as a second-gift opportunity for the beginning of next year. Waiting for January to build those relationships puts your team behind before the new calendar earns its first coffee stain. Steve reminds us: “It’s about people and how you make people feel.”
What does memorable follow-up look like? Steve donates to 25 Bloomerang customers each Giving Tuesday and watches what happens next. One particular organization uses 3 touches: an immediate phone call, a handwritten note the following week, and a brief impact report a week later. . . . .. That’s a relationship getting attention!
The conversation also tackles revenue concentration risk. Depending on a handful of foundations deserves a diversification plan, but fear shouldn’t send your team into hiding from its strongest supporters. Steve encourages leaders to communicate with confidence: “You should have relentless optimism and pride in what you’re doing.”
For nonprofit executives and board members, there’s a management lesson, too: establish fundraising goals, then report monthly on donor retention, second-gift conversion, recurring donors, and top donors. Ground board conversations in a clear 12–24-month direction and explain where board members can help.
Watch this with your NPO’s development, finance, and leadership teams. Then choose one improvement to your donor follow-up and one improvement to your board reporting before January arrives. This will get your new year flourishing!!
Key Takeaways:
– Treat year-end gifts as the opening of a second-gift opportunity.
– Resource retention alongside acquisition, recurring giving, and donor reactivation.
– Use the three-touch stewardship example to review your follow-up.
– Assess funding concentration while strengthening major-funder relationships.
– Report monthly fundraising metrics against an agreed plan.
– Prepare a compelling explanation of what additional funding could accomplish.