Want to know how to reduce donor fatigue when your fundraising team is already running on fumes? On Fundraisers Friday, Julia C. Patrick and Tony Beall show how to read a dip in giving, rethink your year-end donor communications, and give an overloaded team some breathing room!

Start with the numbers. If donor retention is slipping, compare your own data with giving trends in your nonprofit subsector. Tony points to Giving USA, Bloomerang research, and AFP Global as places to look for context. An arts organization can learn more by looking at arts giving trends alongside its own results than by trying to explain a local decline with a national headline.

Then look at what donors actually receive. Oversolicitation was the most consistent explanation Tony encountered in his research for the episode. His example sounds familiar: two or three email blasts in a week, then a text, then a phone call. Add an appeal that says “now more than ever,” a line he’s been hearing for 20 years, and it’s easy to see why even loyal supporters might tune out. . . .

Julia brings a good test to your next newsletter or eblast. If you removed the ask, would you still have something worth sending? A story about what a gift made possible, a program milestone, or a development in the field gives supporters a reason to keep opening your messages would be better.

The two also get honest about the workload behind those campaigns. Tony recalls spinning 10 to 12 plates a day as a development director. Skilled volunteers can take on thank-you calls, writing, and marketing, while sharing results with colleagues in accounting, security, and across the organization helps everyone see what their work makes possible.

Key Takeaways:

– Compare your donor retention trend with giving trends in your own nonprofit subsector.

– Review email, text, phone, and mail together for overlapping asks.

– Build impact updates into your stewardship calendar alongside appeals.

– Match skilled volunteers to thank-you calls, writing, and marketing.

– Share mission outcomes and progress toward revenue goals across departments.